Thing with the crafting alts is that other than gathering, a rank 1 alt works just as well as a rank 40 main. Everyone already has the ability to be completely self sufficient - the reason that didn't happen already is that some people really do hate crafting

. I do however kinda agree with you on the economy thing though - as this is a private server we probably want to encourage as much trading as possible.
Failing that, a way of passing on Bound To Player items to somebody else so they can be salvaged would be very handy (this might already exist, I haven't played in over a year and looked at crafting much longer than that). Butcher and Scavenging could be combined into one skill too as they are basically the same thing. You would be left with:
Gathering:
[*]Butering/Scavenging (combined)
[*]Cultivation
[*]Magical Salvaging (can pass on all items that can be salvaged, perhaps by going down the shattered item route? Item would be unrepairable obviously otherwise that would just get around the point of Bound to Player)
Crafting:
[*]Apothecary
[*]Talisman Making